Since 2015, the Emmys have recognized two dominant shows in the variety category – “Last Week Tonight With John Oliver” in the variety talk category and “Saturday Night Live” in the variety sketch category. However, in 2023, these two juggernauts will compete against each other due to a rule change that merges the categories into outstanding scripted variety series. This change adds another layer of competition and uncertainty as voters will have to choose between a wider array of choices.
In the past, “Last Week Tonight” has had the upper hand, consistently beating out big names in late-night talk shows like “The Late Show With Stephen Colbert,” “Jimmy Kimmel Live!,” and “The Daily Show With Trevor Noah.” On the other hand, “SNL” has had a smaller field to conquer, often competing against only one other nominee, such as “A Black Lady Sketch Show.” Despite the smaller competition, “SNL” has managed to secure wins.
Comparing “Last Week Tonight” and “SNL” is like comparing apples and oranges. “Last Week Tonight” features deeply researched essays with jokes, covering a range of topics like cryptocurrency, farmworkers, and artificial intelligence. In contrast, “SNL” relies mostly on silliness with breakout sketches like “Lisa From Temecula.” The two shows have distinct styles and approaches, making it difficult to predict an outcome.
However, the outstanding scripted variety series category is not limited to just these two shows. It also includes contenders like “A Black Lady Sketch Show,” “Inside Amy Schumer,” “History of the World: Part II,” “Ziwe,” “The Amber Ruffin Show,” and “Documentary Now!” Each show brings a unique comedic style, ranging from Borscht Belt stylings to clever gotcha questions. While it would be disappointing if the category results in another victory for “Last Week Tonight” or “SNL,” it’s challenging to imagine one of them not emerging as the winner, given their track record and institutional appeal.
Related Post
With the heavyweights competing in scripted variety, the question arises about the future of the variety talk category without “Last Week Tonight.” The last time Oliver didn’t win, the trophy went to Jon Stewart’s final season of “The Daily Show.” Trevor Noah’s departure from “The Daily Show” was more complicated, leaving midseason and putting guest hosts in charge. Another potential contender in the variety talk category is Stephen Colbert or Jimmy Kimmel, who have yet to win a Primetime Emmy for their current talk shows. Alternatively, “Late Night With Seth Meyers” could finally receive recognition in the 12:35 a.m. slot.
Both the variety talk and scripted variety categories will be influenced by the WGA strike, as shows like “SNL” and “Last Week Tonight” had shortened seasons. Late-night shows, except for “Gutfeld!,” are currently on hiatus due to the strike. While the strike doesn’t negate what was already produced, it emphasizes the immediate impact on this corner of the industry.
The TV Academy has struggled to define and categorize shows like “Last Week Tonight” and “SNL,” which have evolved beyond traditional formats. Comparing these shows is challenging, but the Emmys are pushing voters to make a choice between pure goofiness and goofiness with educational elements.
In conclusion, the merge of the variety talk and variety sketch categories into outstanding scripted variety series adds a layer of uncertainty and competition. While “Last Week Tonight” and “SNL” have historically dominated their respective categories, this rule change opens the field to a broader range of contenders. It remains to be seen whether the Emmys will continue to favor established institutions or if a new show will break through and claim the prize.
