The highly anticipated crossover episode between “Strange New Worlds” and “Lower Decks” has finally arrived, and it does not disappoint. This episode, entitled “Those Old Scientists,” takes the beloved characters of Tawny Newsome’s Mariner and Jack Quaid’s Boimler from the animated world of “Lower Decks” and brings them into the live-action universe of “Strange New Worlds.” After an early screening at Comic-Con, the episode is now available to watch on Paramount Plus.
The episode begins with the beta shift, comprised of animated characters, conducting a routine survey of a long-dormant time-travel portal. Boimler and Tendi engage in a friendly argument about the origin of the portal, with Boimler claiming it was discovered by Starfleet and Tendi asserting that it was the work of Orion scientists. This playful banter highlights the ongoing desire to dispel stereotypes and misconceptions, such as the belief that all Orions are pirates.
However, the situation takes an unexpected turn when Boimler accidentally activates the time portal and finds himself transported to the live-action world of “Strange New Worlds.” Upon arrival, he is greeted by the iconic characters Spock, Una, and La’an. The episode cleverly incorporates an animated version of the title sequence, complete with a nacelle-sucking alien, further blurring the boundaries between the two shows.
On the Enterprise, Boimler is overcome with awe and excitement at being in the presence of his childhood heroes. However, he struggles to reconcile the differences between his perception of these characters based on the Star Trek legend and the reality of their present-day storylines in “Strange New Worlds.” This aspect of the episode humorously pokes fun at obsessive fans who become preoccupied with policing the boundaries of what Star Trek should be, instead of simply embracing the joy of the journey.
Meanwhile, the Enterprise faces a new challenge in the form of an Orion vessel with unknown intentions, which manages to steal the time portal. Boimler urges Captain Pike to approach the situation diplomatically, but his enthusiasm inadvertently leads to a controversial trade involving much-needed triticale grain. Pike reluctantly agrees to the trade, even though it results in the forced relocation of starving colonists, as he deems it preferable to having Boimler on his ship any longer.
As the episode progresses, Mariner discovers the predicament facing Boimler and valiantly leaps through the time portal to come to his rescue. However, they soon realize that the portal only has enough power for one trip, leaving them stranded in the live-action world. The Enterprise crew, including the previously passive observers from the lower decks, must come together to find a solution.
In a clever twist, Boimler and Mariner discover that the Enterprise itself possesses a fuel source that can be refined from a component of the NX-01. This revelation highlights the interconnectedness of the Star Trek universe and pays homage to the naval tradition of incorporating components from previous vessels in the construction of new ships. Ultimately, with the help of the Orions, who agree to take credit for the discovery of the portal, Boimler and Mariner are able to return to their animated world.
“Those Old Scientists” is a delightful blend of fan service and comedic storytelling. It successfully captures the spirit of both “Strange New Worlds” and “Lower Decks,” providing an entertaining crossover experience for fans of both shows. The episode benefits from the excellent comedic timing of the cast, with Carol Kane delivering standout moments that leave viewers grinning from ear to ear.
However, there is a slight drawback to the episode. While it is undeniably enjoyable, it lacks depth beyond the initial rush of excitement. The majority of scenes involve Boimler and Mariner expressing their admiration for the Enterprise crew, rather than actively participating in the narrative. This sidelines the lower deckers, who could have showcased their dynamic and resourceful characters in a more compelling way.
Nevertheless, “Those Old Scientists” is a delightful treat for Star Trek enthusiasts. It embodies the spirit of fan service, showcasing the beloved characters from “Lower Decks” in the live-action world of “Strange New Worlds.” Despite its minor flaws, the episode is a testament to the joy and excitement that comes with being a Star Trek fan. With both “Strange New Worlds” and “Lower Decks” in production simultaneously, this is undoubtedly a thrilling time to be part of the Star Trek universe.
