Prequels often face limitations when it comes to storytelling, especially for well-known properties. The audience already knows where the characters and storylines will end up, which can restrict the dramatic license of the narrative. Additionally, any deviations from the established canon can be jarring for viewers who are familiar with the existing story. However, Star Trek: Strange New Worlds has managed to navigate this issue successfully by using its well-known conclusion to its advantage.
In the latest episode, “Ad Astra per Aspera,” the series cleverly explores the tragic nature of Captain Pike’s character, knowing that he will eventually face a near-fatal dose of radiation. This creates a compelling and bittersweet story that resonates with the audience. However, the episode also serves as an indictment of prequels in general, revealing the limitations they face in terms of what they can say and do. Despite presenting a world that is hopeful for change, long-time viewers of the Star Trek franchise know that this optimism is misplaced.
This doesn’t mean that “Ad Astra per Aspera” is a bad episode. In fact, it maintains the lightweight and entertaining tone that the series is known for. Star Trek has always excelled in its portrayal of courtroom dramas, and this episode is no exception. The exploration of big issues and the melodramatic nature of the genre are well-executed. Additionally, there are moments of comedy that highlight the fun side of Spock’s character.
The episode follows Number One, who is preparing to stand trial for fraudulently entering Starfleet despite the ban on genetic modification. She reflects on her childhood, where her genetic status caused her parents to worry about seeking medical treatment. Captain Batel, now a member of Starfleet’s legal corps, offers Number One a plea bargain with a dishonorable discharge. However, she refuses to accept this fate, leading Captain Pike to seek the help of Neera, an Illyrian lawyer and former friend of Number One.
Related Post
The story unfolds as a courtroom drama, focusing on the reasons behind Number One’s decision to join an organization that discriminates against her. It is revealed that she was inspired by the diverse crews of Starfleet, but this alone is not enough to win her case. Neera manages to find a contradiction between the Federation’s ideals and its laws, providing a subtle critique of the “California liberal paradox.” The episode suggests that while some progress is made in the courtroom, prejudice and legal barriers will persist.
Ultimately, Number One is found not guilty and is allowed to return to active duty on the Enterprise. The episode ends on a hopeful note, with Neera stating that Number One’s visibility as an Illyrian in a position of power will help change people’s hearts and minds. However, long-time Star Trek viewers know that this change doesn’t happen. The episode adds a tragic layer of depth for dedicated fans, as they are aware that genetic modifications continue to be discriminated against in the Star Trek universe.
What initially seemed like a limitation of the episode’s storytelling is now viewed as a smart commentary on the difficulty of achieving justice and societal change. The struggle to bend the arc of history towards a fair and inclusive future is highlighted, and the episode becomes a poignant exploration of these themes. The writers, Dana Horgan and Valerie Weiss, deserve praise for their pointed storytelling.
In conclusion, “Ad Astra per Aspera” faces the challenges that prequels often encounter in terms of storytelling limitations. However, Star Trek: Strange New Worlds manages to navigate these limitations by using the well-known conclusion of the characters’ stories to its advantage. The episode serves as both an indictment of prequels and a poignant exploration of justice and societal change. Fans of the franchise will appreciate the depth and thoughtfulness of the storytelling, even if it doesn’t ultimately change the established Star Trek canon.
