The technology industry is not pleased with Arkansas’ recent law that requires social media age checks. NetChoice, a tech trade group that includes Google, Meta, and TikTok, has taken legal action against the state of Arkansas, claiming that the law violates the US Constitution’s First Amendment. According to NetChoice, the law infringes on free speech rights by forcing users to provide private data in order to access social networks. Additionally, the law is said to take decision-making power away from families.
NetChoice also argues that the law undermines privacy and safety by requiring internet companies to rely on a third-party service to store and track children’s data. They claim that Arkansas residents are often unfamiliar with or unassociated with this service, making it a prime target for potential hacks. The lawsuit argues that the law attempts to regulate the internet outside of both state and federal laws. Since Arkansas cannot verify residency without requiring data, the law effectively forces everyone to submit personal documents.
In response to the lawsuit, State Attorney General Tim Griffin has stated that he intends to vigorously defend the Social Media Safety Act. The law mandates age verification for all users, requiring them to submit their driver’s licenses or utilize other “commercially reasonable” methods. Individuals under the age of 18 must also obtain parental consent. However, there are exceptions that seem to cover major social networks and related categories, such as professional networking platforms like LinkedIn or short entertaining video clip apps like TikTok.
Arkansas’ age verification requirement is part of a larger trend among politicians who are pushing for similar measures across the country. States like Utah, Connecticut, and Ohio have already passed or are considering laws that require age verification for social media use. Senator Josh Hawley has even proposed a federal bill that would ban social media access for children under 16. The concern driving these initiatives is that younger users might be exposed to inappropriate content or potential predators, and that social media use could negatively impact their mental health by distorting their perception of the world and encouraging addiction.
Related Post
While there is no guarantee that the lawsuit will be successful, its outcome could have significant implications for other attempts to verify users’ ages through personal data. If Arkansas’ approach is deemed unconstitutional, other states may be forced to abandon similar efforts.
In conclusion, the technology industry, represented by NetChoice, is challenging Arkansas’ social media age verification law, arguing that it violates First Amendment rights and compromises privacy and safety. The state, on the other hand, is determined to defend the law and its provisions for age verification and parental consent. The outcome of the legal action could have wider implications for similar initiatives in other states.
